The balance of power between workers and their bosses is shifting. The exchange of value has shifted from the transactional factors of fair pay for a day’s work, to a more nuanced set of relational factors – and this is proving tricky for employers to grasp. By Rebecca Houghton.
Employers are out of touch with employee expectations. Well, stop the press. I’m fairly sure that this has been going on since the industrial revolution. Of course they are – there’s a natural disconnect between senior executive priorities and the priorities of the workforce. In fact, their roles, reporting lines and rewards are so often opposed, you’d be forgiven for thinking we designed it to guarantee a disconnect.
However, unlike most periods since the industrial revolution, the balance of power between workers and their bosses is shifting, as shows in PwC’s latest Global Workforce Hopes & Fears Survey.
And as a result, the exchange of value has shifted from the transactional factors of fair pay for a day’s work, to a more nuanced set of relational factors – and this is proving tricky for employers to grasp.
Our workers expect our managers to put in more discretionary effort, in return for which they may be treated favourably when a better offer comes along. This shouldn’t be an unfamiliar scenario – it’s just that the shoe is on the other foot. And it’s uncomfortable.
This is why so many leaders are confusing historically-motivating factors with what are now considered table-stakes by employees. On the job training, access to coaching and mentoring, and a commitment to the environment are simply not motivating, they are baseline expectations.
Yet in the PWC what-workers-want report, factors like working with good coworkers, the ability to work from home, autonomy, and pensions and superannuation were routinely undervalued by leadership, and by a significant margin. Other studies illustrate how consistently and significantly managers over-rate how much they recognise, reward and care for their staff – compared to what the staff think about that.
And it’s not just leaders versus the workforce – HR is in the mix as well. Gartner found that only 29 percent of employees agreed with the statement, “HR really understands what people like me need and want.”
And why? Because HR priorities reflect the C-Suite priorities, and when they can’t influence a shift in those on behalf of the workforce, then they are failing to provide a clear path for success.
So why does this matter? When the disconnect is this severe, it disconnects the entire organisational structure. Workforce and Executive become Us and Them. HR is untrusted, and viewed as a mouthpiece of the Executive, and middle managers fade into the background or crumble entirely under the pressure of these conflicting expectations.
No one is on the same page, and corporate cohesion becomes corporate conflict. Just look at your return to workplace discussions and you’ll see exactly what I mean. What to do?
This disconnect is not insurmountable, and it really boils down to better communication flowing through your organisational structure – and by communication, I don’t mean telling. I mean asking, listening and then taking action.
The change in communication is yet another symptom of the shift from transactional – top-down comms that ‘tells’ people what’s happening – to relational – two-way conversations with real intent and outcomes.
The fix? Your missing middle managers, who I call the B-Suite. The problem is, only one in three managers are engaged at work and manager-level burnout is high. So if you’re looking to retain these valuable assets, here’s three things to consider:
Engage them: Bring them into the tent and share this challenge to see what insights they have, and what role they can play in reconnecting the disconnect. They are the only cohort that can connect at a personal level with their workforce, and still have the enterprise maturity to understand the needs of both employer and employee – but they can’t do it if you’re not engaging with them all the time. If you simply expect them to execute executive orders, you’ll be increasingly disappointed.
Redefine their roles: The role of the B-Suite has changed astronomically over the last five years, and the range at which they are now expected to operate is vast. Yet expectations on the role of manager are also miles apart. HR expects the B-Suite to facilitate transformation, improve team agility and drive high performance, when the B-Suite is struggling just to keep the lights on – citing team burnout, monitoring team workload and hiring new staff as their major challenges. Before you set out to resolve workforce expectations, you need to redress the expectations of the B-Suite.
Equip and empower them: If your leaders aren’t leading it’s not because they don’t want to, it’s because they’ve been neither equipped with the know-how, nor empowered with the autonomy to do so. Equip them first – train them to know when to escalate, delegate and negotiate – then let them lead. M
Rebecca Houghton, author of Impact: 10 Ways to Level up your Leadership ($29.95), is a leadership and talent expert and founder of BoldHR. Rebecca builds B-Suite leaders with C-Suite impact by working at an organisational, team and individual level. www.boldhr.com.au
